Showing posts with label divorce. Show all posts
Showing posts with label divorce. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

How Custody Evaluators Think about Domestic Violence

Posted: 06/30/11 04:34 AM ET

One of the most challenging aspects of custody decisions is the issue of domestic violence. About 20% of divorces require judges to appoint a custody evaluator to assist in the determination of custody arrangements. There are a wide range of estimates (50% - 90%) of the extent to which these divorce cases involve aggression and violence. One of the central questions that the custody evaluator must decide is whether the domestic violence is likely to continue and how to handle custody arrangements in a way that does not put family members at-risk of further violence. At present there are no universal standards for conducting custody evaluations and most custody evaluators have little training in domestic violence. 

In a recent study Megan Haselschwerdt, Jennifer Hardesty and Jason Hans (Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 2011) examined how custody evaluators think about domestic violence in their decisions regarding custody. They conducted in-depth interviews with a small sample (N=23) of custody evaluators that had on average about 14 years of experience conducting evaluations. 

Even among behavioral scientists there has been much debate about the nature of domestic violence. Professor Michael Johnson at the University of Michigan has clarified the dispute by explaining that there are two major types of domestic violence. On the one hand, some violence is the result of stressful situations in which husbands or wives lash out in physical or verbal aggression. He called this "situational violence." On the other hand, some domestic violence involves the use of extreme forms of control that forces a partner to do something she does not want to do. Johnson labeled this form of violence as "intimate terrorism." He also notes that in addition to physical violence, intimate terrorists use psychological abuse, isolation and intimidation to control their partners. 

Custody evaluators are likely to encounter couples who are engaged in both types of violent situations. How custody evaluators assess violence can influence their recommendations about custody outcomes. These researchers found that custody evaluators tended to hold a view that either viewed violence as situational violence or intimate terrorism. 

The custody evaluators whose views tended towards viewing aggression as situational violence reported less training in domestic violence. This group generally viewed domestic violence as stress induced, normative and mutual. As a result, these evaluators minimized spouse abuse as relevant to child custody decisions. They also thought that false allegations of violence were common. In terms of custody and parenting plans, they prioritized coparenting and father-child relationships. 

On the other hand, custody evaluators who characterized domestic violence as intimate terrorism took a different view of custody. They were more likely to report extensive training in domestic violence. These evaluators viewed spouse abuse as a significant factor in determining child custody. They thought that false allegations of abuse were rare. This group of evaluators distinguished between types of violence and expressed strong views that custody and parenting plans should be different for each of these types of violence. In the case of intimate terrorism, they prioritized victim safety over ongoing contact with fathers. 

Although based on a small sample of custody evaluators, these findings raise important questions about the degree to which domestic violence is being thoughtfully considered in custody decisions. It is important for the legal system to develop training and policies such that custody evaluators can appropriately consider custody arrangements in domestic violence situations.

FOR MORE INFORMATION: 
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/robert-hughes/how-custody-evaluators-th_b_886703.html?ref=email_share

Thursday, May 26, 2011

CDC: Majority of U.S. adults had troubled childhoods

USA TODAY
Updated 12/17/2010 8:18 PM
Almost 60% of American adults say they had difficult childhoods featuring abusive or troubled family members or parents who were absent due to separation or divorce, federal health officials report.
 
In fact, nearly 9% said that while growing up they underwent five or more "adverse childhood experiences" ranging from verbal, physical or sexual abuse to family dysfunction such as domestic violence, drug or alcohol abuse, or the absence of a parent, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

"Adverse childhood experiences are common," said study coauthor Valerie J. Edwards, team lead for the Adverse Childhood Experiences Team at CDC's National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. "We need to do a lot more to protect children and help families," she said.

About a quarter of the more than 26,000 adults surveyed reported experiencing verbal abuse as children, nearly 15% had been physical abused, and more than 12% — more than one in 10 — had been sexually abused as a child.

Since the data are self-reported, Edwards believes that the real extent of child abuse may be still greater. "There is a tendency to under-report rather than over-report," she said.

The findings are published in the Dec. 17 issue of the CDC's journal Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report.
For the report, researchers used data from the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System, which surveyed 26,229 adults in Arkansas, Louisiana, New Mexico, Tennessee and Washington. Edwards is cautious about extrapolating these results, but based on other data they probably are about the same in other states, she said.

While there were few racial or ethnic differences in reports of abuse, the report confirmed that women were more likely than men to have been sexually abused as children. In addition, people 55 and older were less likely to report being abused as a child compared to younger adults.

One theory why older people did not report as much childhood abuse is that since these takes a toll on health in adulthood, many of these older abuse victims may have died early, Edwards said. The CDC report, for example, notes that adverse childhood experiences are associated with a higher risk of depression, heart disease, diabetes, cancer, substance abuse and premature death. "So (childhood abuse) may be associated with years of life lost," she said.

There was no difference in the number of people reporting childhood abuse in any other age group, Edwards added.

Adverse childhood experiences included in the report included verbal abuse, physical abuse, sexual abuse, incarceration of a family member, family mental illness, family substance abuse, domestic violence and divorce.

According to the report, about 7.2% had had a family member in prison during their childhood and 16.3% had witnessed domestic violence in the family home. In addition, about 29% grew up in a home where someone abused alcohol or drugs. "These cases occur across all racial groups and ethnicities," Edwards noted.

Almost one in five respondents (19.4 percent) had lived as a child with someone who was depressed, mentally ill or suicidal, the report noted.

Although the volume of abuse and dysfunction is significant, such traumatic experiences cannot be used to describe a person or determine what that person will be, the researchers cautioned. Instead, they said, keeping track of these abusive experiences is important to gain a better understanding of them and their effect on society.

In addition, it's crucial to work harder to prevent abuse and household stress as well as finding better ways to identify and treat children at risk, they said.

"For adults who have had these experiences and feel they are still causing them problems, they are not alone and there is help available," Edwards said.

Dr. Lee M. Sanders, an associate professor of pediatrics at the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine said that "one of the things we don't realize when we look around at our neighborhoods and communities is that these problems are so common."

"That's something to be concerned about. That's something to take communal action on," he added.
Identifying and treating abuse early can prevent many serious health consequences later in life. Programs that provide quality care for children, as well as home visitation programs in early infancy and parenting programs, are part of the solution to this problem, Sanders said.

"These interventions are important not just because abuse is so common, but because of the lifelong health implications," Sanders said. "There is a connection of these events to lifelong implications, not just for mental health for adults, but also for physical health."

For example, a person who has several of these events is more likely to get cancer and heart disease, Edwards said. "This is serious and it's not just a quirk of statistics. It's a real relationship."

Saturday, April 16, 2011

CDC Report: Adverse Childhood Experiences Reported by Adults

Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) include verbal, physical, or sexual abuse as well as family dysfunction (an incarcerated, mentally ill, or substance-abusing family member, domestic violence, and absence of a parent due to divorce or separation).

Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) have been linked to a wide range of health outcomes in adulthood including substance abuse, depression, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, cancer, and premature mortality.


Using the 2009 ACE module of the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) to examine whether a history of ACEs was common, 26,229 adults were interviewed in 5 states- Arkansas, Louisiana, New Mexico, Tennessee, and Washington. The MMWR report on ACEs among U.S. adults summarizes the results of that analysis. The module consisted of 11 questions that yielded 8 categories of ACEs (verbal abuse, physical abuse, sexual abuse, household mental illness, household substance abuse, domestic violence, parental separation/divorce and incarcerated family members). Respondents were asked to refer to the time period before they were 18 years of age when answering questions.


Overall, 59.4% of respondents reported having had at least one ACE while 8.7% reported five or more ACEs. Given the high prevalence of ACEs, additional efforts are needed at the state and local level to reduce and prevent childhood maltreatment and associated family dysfunction in the US, and further the development and dissemination of trauma-focused services to treat stress-related health outcomes associated with ACEs.
The most common ACEs were:
  • Separated or divorced parents
  • Verbal abuse
  • Family member with depression or mental illness
  • Witness of domestic violence
  • Physical abuse
  • Sexual abuse

Differences by gender

Men and women reported similar prevalence for having grown up with a mentally ill household member (22.0% for women, 16.7% for men) and growing up with a substance-abusing family member (30.6% for women, 27.5% for men). A difference between men and women was observed in the ACE category of sexual abuse, where women reported more than twice as many experiences as men (17.2% for women, 6.7% for men).

Differences by race/ethnicity

Black, non-Hispanic respondents had the lowest prevalence of each ACE category among all racial-ethnic groups. However, compared to all racial-ethnic groups Black non-Hispanics reported higher prevalence of having had an incarcerated family member (12.9%) and experiencing parental divorce (37.9%). Compared to Whites, Hispanics more frequently reported physical abuse (14.6% for Whites, 19.8% for Hispanics), witnessing domestic violence (15.1% for Whites, 21.7% for Hispanics), and having an incarcerated family member (6.2% for Whites, 9.5% for Hispanics).


These findings reinforce that adverse childhood experiences are common across racial/ethnic groups and states, further reinforcing the need to expand evidence-based child abuse prevention programs such as home visiting and parent education.

Chart: Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) Among Adult Respondents by Race/Ethnicity; 5 States, 2009 — White, non-Hispanic – 0: 41.7%; 1: 22.0%; 2: 12.7%; 3: 8.7%; 4: 6.0%; ≥5: 8.9%. Black, non-Hispanic – 0: 37.3%; 1: 27.0%; 2: 13.8%; 3: 8.9%; 4: 8.0%; ≥5: 4.9%. Hispanic – 0: 35.7%; 1: 23.5%; 2: 12.9%; 3: 10.3%; 4: 8.6%; ≥5: 9.1%. Other, non-Hispanic: 0: 37.8%; 1: 18.2%; 2: 16.4%; 3: 8.4%; 4: 7.6%; ≥5: 11.7%. Adult respondents aged ≥18 years from Arkansas, Louisians, New Mexico, Tennessee, and Washington. Percentages may not total 100% due to rounding. Other, non-Hispanic includes: Asian, Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander, American Indian/Alaska Native, other race, multi-race. Data Source: Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS).

Data Source

CDC. Adverse Childhood Experiences Reported by Adults — Five States, 2009. MMWR 59(49);1609-1613.

More Information